Over 15 years in Napa Valley, Castello di Amorosa has received a wide range of high scores from some of the most respected wine critics in the industry. Below are some of the highest-rated wines in our history—each reflecting exceptional vintages and the unique character of their vineyards.
These highly collectible wines offer tremendous aging potential. You can explore more of our wine accolades or browse our top scoring wines.
Special thanks to Wine Enthusiast, Wine Spectator, James Suckling, Vinous Media, Wine Review Online, and Jeb Dunnuck for their continued recognition.
1) 2014 Morisoli-Borges Cabernet Sauvignon – 98 Points
Sustainably farmed by a fourth-generation family, this Rutherford vineyard produces a wine defined by its signature “dust” character and silky tannins. A standout vintage with exceptional depth and balance.
98 Points – Jeb Dunnuck
“Layered, gorgeously pure, concentrated and always elegant and silky… enjoy this blockbuster anytime over the coming decades.”
Tasting Notes: Crème de cassis, blueberry, graphite, and violet.
Vintage Notes: A warm, dry season produced smaller berries with concentrated flavors and excellent balance.
2) 2016 Melanson Cabernet Sauvignon – 97 Points
Grown on a rugged hillside above the fog line, this vineyard benefits from exceptional sun exposure and volcanic soils, producing fruit with intense concentration and structure.
97 Points – The Wine Advocate
“Built like a brick house… firm, grainy texture with tons of freshness and a long finish.”
Tasting Notes: Dark cherry, cassis, plum, and chocolate.
Vintage Notes: A strong rebound vintage with excellent structure and aging potential.
3) 2018 Sinalunga Cabernet Sauvignon – 97 Points
Crafted in tribute to the Sinalunga region, this limited-production Cabernet reflects passion, heritage, and meticulous winemaking.
97 Points – Jeb Dunnuck
“Powerful, concentrated… full-bodied richness with terrific balance.”
Tasting Notes: Cassis, dark cherry, graphite, and pomegranate.
Vintage Notes: A well-balanced vintage with bright acidity and deep color.
4) 2016 Don Thomas Cabernet Sauvignon – 96 Points
A rare release from a six-acre vineyard in Rutherford, known for its exceptional sunlight and ideal growing conditions for Cabernet Sauvignon.
96 Points – The Wine Advocate
“Tautly structured with ripe tannins and beautiful freshness… long and mineral-laced.”
Tasting Notes: Blueberry, raspberry, currant, and rose.
Vintage Notes: Early harvest with excellent flavor development and structure.
