In Defense Of Napa Valley’s Veteran Wine Hero

Mary Davidek • November 7, 2013

I was at a dinner party a couple of weeks ago and the subject of Napa Valley wine came up. Not shocking—but this time the focus was Chardonnay. Maybe it was the season, maybe the company, or maybe the wine I brought. :contentReference[oaicite:0]{index=0}

Castello di Amorosa Chardonnay wine bottles

Years ago, I attended an “Anything But Chardonnay” dinner. Critics called it “too oaky,” “manipulated,” even claiming it pairs with nothing. Simply put—they were wrong.

As we approach Veteran’s Day, perhaps wine lovers should reflect on Chardonnay as one of Napa Valley’s true heroes. After all, it was a California Chardonnay that won the 1976 Paris Tasting, bringing global recognition to Napa Valley.

Chardonnay wine being poured

Chardonnay is the most widely planted white grape in the world. Its styles range from buttery and oaky to crisp and mineral-driven. Modern winemakers now use oak and malolactic fermentation more selectively, allowing for diverse expressions.

While preferences evolve, it’s important to stay open-minded—and sometimes defend the classics that helped shape the industry.

Glass of Chardonnay wine

Chardonnay is often aged sur lie (on the lees), which softens texture and enhances flavor. Oak aging adds depth and complexity, making it one of the few white wines that can benefit from bottle aging.

Chardonnay aging in oak barrel

The 2007 Napa Valley Chardonnay has developed notes of golden apple, pear, and toasted brûlée—perfect for Thanksgiving with harvest salads, candied pecans, and feta.

Chardonnay with cheese and salad pairing

The 2008 Bien Nacido Chardonnay is stunning—layered with vanilla, spice, and bright fruit that remains vivid even with age.

Chardonnay pairing with ahi salad

While not traditional, Chardonnay pairs beautifully with ahi and avocado salad. The wine’s creamy texture complements the richness of avocado, creating a luxurious pairing.

Ahi and Avocado Salad with Ponzu

  • ½ cup ponzu or soy sauce
  • 3 tbsp water
  • 2 tbsp rice vinegar
  • 1 tbsp grated ginger
  • 1 thinly sliced green onion
  • 1½ tsp lime juice with zest
  • Mix well and pour over cubed ahi and avocado
A hand holds an open bottle of white wine next to a filled wine glass on a red table.
By Castello di Amorosa June 14, 2025
Freedom to toast, freedom to choose, freedom to savor — without limits. The post Introducing Libero: Castello di Amorosa’s New Non-Alcoholic Wine Experience appeared first on Castello di Amorosa.
Desserts in glass bowls topped with red glaze, surrounded by blueberries, lemon, mint, and cocktails.
By Castello di Amorosa April 26, 2025
Features the Gioia, Rosato di Sangiovese The post Gioia Jelly with Meyer Lemon Panna Cotta appeared first on Castello di Amorosa.
Punch bowl with fruit slices, cranberries, mint, and ice.
By Castello di Amorosa April 10, 2025
Features our Gewúrztraminer Grape Juice The post Spumante del Castello Sparkling Punch – Wine Recipe appeared first on Castello di Amorosa.
Man and woman toasting with red wine at a table. Wooden interior with music sheet and glass display.
By Castello di Amorosa February 7, 2025
Pair with our Zingaro Old Vine Zinfandel The post Creamy Beef Stroganoff with 2020 Zingaro Old Vine Zinfandel appeared first on Castello di Amorosa.
A close-up of a person smelling a glass of red wine in a dimly lit setting.
By Jim Sullivan February 4, 2025
Unlock the secrets of wine tasting! Learn how to properly taste wine for beginners with expert tips on aroma, flavor, and technique to enhance your experience.
Spaghetti dinner with wine bottle, filled glass, and people seated at a table decorated for the holidays.
By Castello di Amorosa December 3, 2024
Pair with our Morisoli, Sangiovese, and La Castellana The post Bolognese appeared first on Castello di Amorosa.
A tractor kicks up dust while moving between rows of vibrant green grapevines on a sunlit, hillside vineyard.
By Jim Sullivan October 2, 2024
Discover how Castello di Amorosa is revitalizing its estate through vineyard replanting and vine removal, ensuring a sustainable future for wine production.
Cocktail in a glass with mint and a pear, decorated with a pine branch, candle, and berries.
By Castello di Amorosa September 30, 2024
Features our Gewúrztraminer Grape Juice The post Golden Gewürz Fizz appeared first on Castello di Amorosa.
Cocktail in a golden-bottomed glass, garnished with orange and thyme, on a table near greenery and a candle.
By Castello di Amorosa September 28, 2024
Features our Sparkling Red Grape Juice The post Frosted Cherry Twist appeared first on Castello di Amorosa.
Glass of orange cocktail, halved orange, candle, pine boughs, and pinecone on a table.
By Castello di Amorosa September 28, 2024
Features our Muscat Grape Juice The post Winter Citrus Spritz appeared first on Castello di Amorosa.
Show More